The relationship between chemistry and physics from the perspective of Bohmian mechanics
نویسندگان
چکیده
In the practice of chemistry, the problems are set aside or even ignored under the assumption that the link between the chemical and the physical domains is gradual and continuous: chemistry, with its concepts and regularities, would arise as the result of applying different approximations to the quantum descriptions. However, during the last years many authors have stressed the conceptual breakdown between the two domains (Woolley 1978, Primas 1983, 1998, Amann 1992, Lombardi and Labarca 2005, Labarca and Lombardi 2010). More recently, Hinne Hettema (2012, p. 368) recognizes the “ontological discontinuity” between chemistry and physics: certain terms, used both in chemistry and in physics, refer to different items in the two disciplines. According to this author, such discontinuity is “one of the central problems in the philosophy of chemistry, around which many other problems, such as that of reduction, revolve.” (Hettema 2012, p. 368).
منابع مشابه
The impact of P/E ratio and price return on the stock market Bohmian quantum potential approach
Price return and P/E are two important factors for a lot of investors based on the latest studies by researchers in Tehran Stock market; however, it is expected that the price and the variation of that affect the return and the P/E of any given market as a complicated system. The Bohmian quantum mechanics used referring to the time correlation of return and P/E of the stock market under conside...
متن کاملBOOK REVIEW Bohmian Mechanics and Quantum Theory
This collection Bohmian Mechanics and Quantum Theory gives us the broadest perspective yet on this important realist alternative to standard quantum theory. The book treats the history, philosophical rami"cations and consistency of theories arising from Bohm's original model and their relations to other alternative theories. Signi"cantly, it also contains applications of these theories to pract...
متن کاملThe orbital: a pivotal concept in the relationship between chemistry and physics? A comment to the work by Fortin and coauthors
The present work is a comment of a recent paper by Fortin and coauthors (Fortin 2017) in which the authors propose the introduction of Bohmian mechanics (BM) in the philosophy of chemistry and the use of standard quantum mechanics (SQM) as a mere instrument of prediction. This way would allow overcoming the obstacles found in linking molecular chemistry and quantum mechanics. Starting from some...
متن کاملBohmian Mechanics and Quantum Information ∗
Many recent results suggest that quantum theory is about information, and that quantum theory is best understood as arising from principles concerning information and information processing. At the same time, by far the simplest version of quantum mechanics, Bohmian mechanics, is concerned, not with information but with the behavior of an objective microscopic reality given by particles and the...
متن کاملمطالعه انتشار همدوس لپتونهای باردار ناشی از واپاشی پایون و W بوزون در مکانیک بوهمی
Although charged leptons, contrary to neutrinos, cannot oscillate, exploring whether a coherent superposition of charged lepton states can change to others during the propagation is an important problem in the neutrino oscillation theory. In this paper, we consider electrons and muons coming from the pions and W decays and study their propagation in relativistic Bohmian quantum mechanics. We f...
متن کامل